The oldest argument: a changed life
Evidence for Christianity: the skeptics’ questions
Long before the modern apologetics shelf, the faith made its case through the lives it changed — and most tellingly through the skeptics and opponents who set out against it and were won. These are first-person accounts of exactly that: reason, resistance, and transformation, free to read in the public domain and offered here as clean editions.
The book that refused to be written
“Such briefly was the purpose of the book which I had planned. I wanted to take this last phase of the life of Jesus, with all its quick and pulsating drama, its sharp clearcut background of antiquity, and its tremendous psychological and human interest, and to strip it of its overgrowth of primitive beliefs and dogmatic suppositions, to see this supremely great person as he really was.”
“I will only say that it effected a revolution in my thought. Things emerged from that old-world story which previously I should have thought impossible.”
“Whilst all this was going on, Doctor Wuzar Khan and Maulvi Mohammed Mazhar, and other leading Muslims, appointed me to preach the Quran and the Hadith in the large royal mosque at Agra, with the view of opposing the Rev. Dr. Pfander.”
Did the apostles die for a lie?
“These men could not be deceivers. By only not bearing testimony, they might have avoided all these sufferings, and have lived quietly. Would men in such circumstances pretend to have seen what they never saw; assert facts which they had no knowledge of; go about lying to teach virtue; and, though not only convinced of Christ’s being an impostor, but having seen the success of his imposture in his crucifixion, yet persist in carrying it on; and so persist, as to bring upon themselves for nothing, and with a full knowledge of the consequence, enmity and hatred, danger and death?”
“Now, that any men, who firmly believed that God would punish them for speaking an untruth, though for the advancement of a good cause, should, at the hazard of their lives, and without any prospect of gain or advantage, assert facts, which, at the same time, they knew to be false; should, for instance, affirm, that they saw and conversed with Jesus Christ after his resurrection, knowing or believing that he was not risen from the dead, and yet expect to be judged hereafter by that very same Jesus, is too improbable to gain credit with any, but those great believers of absurdities, the infidels and sceptics.”
“How hard this sacrifice was to a man of his warm temper, and above all men, to a Jew, is worth consideration. That nation is known to have been more tenacious of their religious opinions than any other upon the face of the earth. The strictest and proudest sect among them was that of the Pharisees, under whose discipline St. Paul was bred. The departing, therefore, so suddenly from their favorite tenets, renouncing their pride, and from their disciple becoming their adversary, was a most difficult effort for one to make so nursed up in the esteem of them, and whose early prejudices were so strongly confirmed by all the power of habit, all the authority of example, and all the allurements of honor and interest. These were the sacrifices he had to make in becoming a Christian; let us now see what inconveniences he had to fear: the implacable vengeance of those he deserted; that sort of contempt which is hardest to bear, the contempt of those whose good opinion he had most eagerly sought, and all those other complicated evils which he describes in his second epistle to the Corinthians, chapter 11 — evils, the least of which were enough to have frighted any impostor even from the most hopeful and profitable cheat. But where the advantage proposed bears no proportion to the dangers incurred, or the mischiefs endured, he must be absolutely out of his senses who will either engage in an imposture, or, being engaged, persevere.”
“Upon the whole, then, I think I have proved that the desire of wealth, or fame, or of power, could be no motive to make St. Paul a convert to Christ; but that, on the contrary, he must have been checked by that desire, as well as by the just apprehension of many inevitable and insupportable evils, from taking a part so contradictory to his past life, to all the principles he had imbibed, and all the habits he had contracted.”
Do the Gospels contradict each other on the resurrection?
“I know not a more rash or unphilosophical conduct of the understanding, than to reject the substance of a story by reason of some diversity in the circumstances with which it is related. The usual character of human testimony is substantial truth under circumstantial variety. This is what the daily experience of courts of justice teaches. When accounts of a transaction come from the mouths of different witnesses, it is seldom that it is not possible to pick out apparent or real inconsistencies between them. These inconsistencies are studiously displayed by an adverse pleader, but oftentimes with little impression upon the minds of the judges. On the contrary, a close and minute agreement induces the suspicion of confederacy and fraud.”
“The contradictions and inconsistencies, which some imagine they have discovered in the evangelical accounts of the resurrection, have been urged as arguments for setting aside the authority, and rejecting the evidence of the Gospels.”
“Some, or all of these things, I say, they would probably have done, had they written in concert. And doubtless they would, nay they must have written in concert, had they endeavoured to impose upon the world a cunningly-devised fable; and had they not trusted to the truth and notoriety of the facts they related. Truth, like honesty, oftentimes neglects appearances. Hypocrisy and imposture are always guarded.”
- 1
1715 · Covenanter Scotland · Answered the deists
Memoirs of the Life of Thomas Halyburton
Thomas Halyburton · 1714
Thomas Halyburton wrestled his way through deism and doubt before returning to faith — an early, rigorous answer to the Enlightenment’s objections, from the inside.
- 2
397 · Roman North Africa · Through the philosophies
Confessions
Augustine · 397
Augustine moved through Manichaeism, skepticism, and Neoplatonism before Christ — the classic account of a searching intellect satisfied at last.
- 3
1885 · Punjab, North India · A Muslim opponent won
A Muslim Brought to Christ
Imad-ud-din Lahiz · 1884
Published as A Mohammedan Brought to Christ (1884)
A Muslim scholar who debated against Christianity — and, studying it to refute it, was won. He wrote his account specifically to prove his conversion was sincere, not bought.
What it cost Almost everyone he knew. His friends and his own students turned on him, most of his relatives stopped speaking to him, and people said he did it for money. His father kept writing. (The Autobiography, last paragraph)
- 4
1922 · India & the Himalayas · Burned the Gospel
At the Master’s Feet
Sadhu Sundar Singh · 1922
Sundar Singh was so hostile he once burned a Bible — then a vision changed everything. A conversion against every incentive of family and culture.
What it cost His family and his home. Born a Sikh, he was disowned and driven out as a teenager, and spent his first night as a Christian under a tree. (his own words, in Streeter and Appasamy, The Sadhu (1921))
- 5
1764 · The Atlantic slave trade · The hardened sailor
An Authentic Narrative
John Newton · 1764
A profane slave-ship captain, by his own testimony beyond reform — the ‘Amazing Grace’ story as evidence that no life is past changing.
- 6
1857 · New England · Freethought reasoned through
The Convert; or, Leaves from My Experience
Orestes Brownson · 1857
Orestes Brownson argued his way through Universalism, socialism, and freethought before entering the Catholic Church — an intellectual’s account of following the reasoning where it led.
What it cost His reputation and many of his readers. He had just made his name in American letters, and becoming a Catholic made him look fickle to Protestants and suspect to Catholics. (ch. XVII–XVIII)
- 7
1925
The Everlasting Man
G.K. Chesterton · 1925
Chesterton’s reply to H. G. Wells’s Outline of History, which had told the story of mankind with man as one animal among others and Christ as one teacher among many. His answer is that both are singular. It is the book C. S. Lewis credited with breaking down his atheism.
- 8
1747
Observations on the History and Evidences of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ
Gilbert West · 1747
West works through the four resurrection accounts as contested testimony and concludes the event is attested. The eighteenth century’s most-cited treatment of the evidence, by a man who had himself entertained deist doubts.
- 9
1930
Who Moved the Stone?
Frank Morison · 1930
A journalist’s attempt to write the book that would put the resurrection to rest, which became the book that could not. Chesterton reviewed it warmly, having picked it up thinking it was a detective story.
- 10
1747
Observations on the Conversion of St. Paul
George Lyttelton · 1747
Lyttelton’s argument that Paul’s conversion alone, examined as evidence, is sufficient proof of Christianity. Published the same year as West’s Evidences, as a letter addressed to him.
- 11
1776
A View of the Internal Evidence of the Christian Religion
Soame Jenyns · 1776
Jenyns argues from the internal character of the Gospels rather than from miracles or prophecy — that no human invention of that era would have produced this particular morality.
- 12
1883
The Life and Times of Jesus the Messiah
Alfred Edersheim · 1883
Edersheim was a Viennese Jew who became a Christian minister, and read the Gospels back into the rabbinic and Talmudic world he had been raised in. Still cited for that reason.
- 13
1857
The Testimony of the Rocks
Hugh Miller · 1857
A self-taught stonemason turned geologist arguing that the rocks and Genesis can be read together — written at the moment that question became urgent, and by someone who knew the rocks first-hand.
- 14
1913 · Florence · Atheist provocateur
The Failure (Un uomo finito)
Giovanni Papini · 1913
Giovanni Papini’s self-portrait of the militant atheist he was — the ‘finished man’ who set out to demolish every faith and would later convert. A firsthand map of the unbelief he came to renounce.
What it cost The name he had made as the Church’s enemy. Raised without faith by an anticlerical father, he announced his conversion in 1919, six years after this book, and went on to write a life of Christ. (Wikipedia, citing his biographers)
Questions about the evidence of changed lives
- Did the apostles die for a lie?
- William Paley, 1794: “These men could not be deceivers. By only not bearing testimony, they might have avoided all these sufferings, and have lived quietly.”
- Do the Gospels contradict each other on the resurrection?
- William Paley, 1794: “I know not a more rash or unphilosophical conduct of the understanding, than to reject the substance of a story by reason of some diversity in the circumstances with which it is related. The usual character of human testimony is substantial truth under circumstantial variety.”
- What is the argument from changed lives?
- It’s one of the oldest and most practical arguments for Christianity: the faith’s power is shown in the lives it transforms — especially the lives of skeptics, scholars, and outright opponents who set out against it and were won. A changed life is evidence you can read firsthand.
- Are these good books for studying apologetics?
- They’re a complement to the argument-based apologetics of writers like Lewis or Chesterton. Where those make the case, these show the result: primary-source accounts of real people reasoning, resisting, and being changed. Good for a class or group studying the evidence for the faith.
- Which is the best example of a skeptic converted?
- George Romanes is the sharpest case — Darwin’s own friend and correspondent, who published an anonymous case against theism as a young man and spent his last years working his way back. Thomas Halyburton answered the deists; Augustine came through the philosophies; and Imad-ud-din, a Muslim scholar, was won while trying to refute Christianity.
- Are the texts free to read?
- All are in the public domain, with a free source linked on each page. Our clean editions add readable typesetting for study.
More reading lists
T.S. Baker — the evidence in their own words, free sources linked.