T.S. Baker
← Changed Lives
A Letter to the Brahmos
Nehemiah GorehT·S·Baker·Books

Free

Our edition, free

The free scan of this book has at least one damaged word in every 30 — we counted. We read it against the original and repaired them. Take the result for nothing — we only ask where to send it, and that you confirm the address.

No subscription — this is a delivery. The original scan is free either way, linked below.

1868 · 100 pages

A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares

by Nehemiah Goreh

Why our edition. In the free scan at least 1 word in 30 is garbled. Ours corrects the damage. The full text is public domain and free — linked below.

On this page: a summary of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares, and our clean edition as a PDF or EPUB.

An open letter from Nehemiah Goreh — born Nilakantha Goreh, once a celebrated Hindu pandit of Benares — addressed to the Brahmo reformers. With the same rigor he had once used to defend Hinduism, he sets out why he came to believe the Christian faith true.

The changed life

He was a Chitpavan Brahmin and renowned Hindu apologist, author of a Sanskrit treatise against Christianity; baptized “Nehemiah” in 1848, he became an Anglican priest, a leading Indian Christian theologian, and in his last years lived with the Cowley Fathers at Poona.

Why Nehemiah Goreh became a Christian

A Brahmin of Benares, he set out to drive the Christian preachers from the city, wrote a Sanskrit refutation of Christianity, and argued with a missionary for three years. A Sanskrit book by John Muir first showed him the religion of the Bible. What moved him in the end was one doctrine.

“It was the doctrine of everlasting punishment, which shook my soul from the very bottom, and forced me to come away at any cost from the path of error.”
Part II

What it cost

His family performed the rite that declares a Hindu dead, and sent his young wife back to her father. In his own words, he went from a respectable man to “a most vile wretch and a fool” in the eyes of everyone he knew.

Part II; Dictionary of Christian Biography in Asia

Summary

A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares is an open letter by Nehemiah Goreh — born Nilakantha Goreh — one of nineteenth-century India’s most formidable Hindu scholars before his conversion. Addressed to the reformers of the Brahmo Samaj, it sets out, with a pandit’s rigor, why he came to hold the Christian faith to be true.

Goreh had once been a defender of orthodox Hinduism who wrote a Sanskrit treatise against Christianity. In this letter he turns that same trained, argumentative mind to the case for Christ, engaging the Brahmos — Hindu reformers who admired Jesus’s ethics while rejecting his divinity — on their own philosophical ground.

The result is less a memoir than a reasoned apologetic from inside Indian religious debate: a converted Brahmin explaining, to fellow Indian intellectuals, the steps by which he was persuaded. It is a primary document of the encounter between Hindu reform movements and Christianity in colonial Bengal.

Who was Nehemiah Goreh?

Nehemiah (Nilakantha) Goreh (1825–1895) was a Chitpavan Brahmin from Benares (Varanasi), celebrated as a learned Hindu pandit and the author of a Sanskrit work refuting Christian doctrine. He came to Christianity through prolonged study and debate and was baptized in 1848, taking the name Nehemiah.

After his conversion he became an Anglican priest and one of the leading Indian Christian theologians of his era, later attaching himself to the Cowley Fathers (the Society of St. John the Evangelist) and spending his last years in their house at Poona. He is also remembered as a spiritual influence on other converts, including Pandita Ramabai — his life a costly, permanent break with the caste and community he had once championed.

Is there an audiobook of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares?

Yes. The complete audiobook of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares by Nehemiah Goreh runs 2 hours 56 minutes, with chapter markers, and is $8.99. It is an unabridged reading of the same edition sold here, delivered as an M4B you download and keep — there is no subscription and no app.

The narration is synthetic: it is read by a text-to-speech voice, not by a human narrator. We say so here, on the buy button and on the receipt, because it is the kind of thing a listener should know before paying rather than after.

Which edition of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares is this?

Our edition is re-OCRed from the original page images rather than taken from the scan’s own text layer, which is poor: we more than halved the error rate and keyed the damaged page-feet by eye against the images. Goreh’s dated demonyms — Hindoo, Hindooism, Mahommedan — are updated to Hindu, Hinduism and Muslim, while Brahman, Brahmin and Brahmo are left alone; his Sanskrit and Marathi footnotes are set as pop-up notes. A note at the front says exactly what was changed and what the scan has lost.

This is a clean, modern reading edition of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares, by Nehemiah (Nilakantha) Goreh. Goreh dated the letter Calcutta, August 1867; this text follows the second edition, printed at the Allahabad Mission Press for the North India Tract Society in 1868. The text is in the public domain.

A note on language. The letter uses the spellings that were standard in English in 1868 — "Hindoo" for a Hindu, "Hindooism" for Hinduism, "Mahommedan" and "Musalman" for a Muslim. Those forms are dated now, and they are not the words the communities concerned use of themselves. In this edition we have updated them to "Hindu", "Hinduism" and "Muslim" throughout the body of the text, so that a modern reader meets Goreh's argument in current language. Goreh's own usage was already mixed — the 1868 printing has "Hindu" and "Hinduism" in a number of places alongside the older forms — so this makes the text more consistent than we found it, not less.

What we have not changed is as important as what we have. Goreh's argument, his voice and his meaning are untouched: he was a Sanskrit pandit of Benares setting out, for fellow Indian intellectuals, why he had come to believe Christianity true, and none of that is softened. We have kept personal names and place names as written. We have kept the work's historical title, under which it has been known and cited since 1868. And we have deliberately left "Brahman", "Brahmin" and "Brahmo" alone: "Brahmo" is the Brahmo Samaj's own name for itself and is current, while "Brahman" in Goreh's pages means both the caste and, in Vedanta, the metaphysical absolute — one spelling doing two jobs, in a book that argues about both. Changing it mechanically would have rewritten his philosophy.

A note on the source. Only one scan of this book is known to exist, and the text layer distributed with it is poor: about one damaged word in thirty-two. We did not use it. We re-OCRed the page images ourselves at 400 dots per inch and corrected the result against those images, which brought the rate to roughly one word in four hundred. Every page of this scan warps at the foot, and the lines that shear there were read by eye rather than guessed. On three pages characters are missing from the image altogether; those are marked, not reconstructed.

Goreh footnotes several of his quotations with the Sanskrit or Marathi original. Those passages have been re-keyed from the page images and appear here as pop-up notes on the English he gives for them.

The free source is linked from this book's page, so any reader can check our edition against the original scan.

A note on the scan. The only surviving scan of this pamphlet is an annotated copy — a previous reader's ink runs across many lines — and on two pages the right-hand margin was cut off by the scanner, taking the last one to three characters of most lines with it. Those characters exist nowhere: the original photographs are clipped in the same way. Where the earlier text of this edition had them filled in with plausible guesses, we have gone back to the page images and restored only what can still be read, and one of those corrections reverses a sentence: Goreh writes that one cannot venture to translate a certain passage, and our earlier text had him saying that one can. The scan also renders the accented a as a d, which is why several Sanskrit titles appeared misspelled; they are given here as the book prints them. Everything changed is recorded in this edition's correction files.

What the free copy says, and what the book says

Quoted from Archive.org’s free text of this book — the text its EPUB and full-text downloads are made from.

  • Free copy

    who has jmrchased Salvation for liim^ by His Kfej Death, and Resurrection

    Our edition

    who has purchased Salvation for him, by His life, Death, and Resurrection

    The only scan was made with the book clamped, so the ends of lines on some pages sit under the clamp. We read them from the page images; where a word is truly lost we say so in brackets.

  • Free copy

    The Stoics held that all crimes were equal. /-«:*?* * I all allow and advise men to continue the ido//*/ Plato,

    Our edition

    The Stoics held that all crimes were equal. Plato, Cicero, Epictetus, all allow and advise men to continue the idolatry of their ancestors.

    A bracketed table in the print, which the scanner turned to wreckage.

  • Free copy

    make the Brahmog agree that they have got this light eni from Christianity

    Our edition

    make the Brahmos agree that they have got this light ent[irely] from Christianity

Common questions

Who was Nehemiah Goreh?
Nehemiah Goreh (1825–1895), born Nilakantha Goreh, was a renowned Brahmin pandit of Benares who had written against Christianity before converting. Baptized in 1848, he became an Anglican priest and a leading Indian Christian theologian.
Who were the Brahmos he wrote to?
The Brahmos were members of the Brahmo Samaj, a Hindu reform movement that admired the moral teaching of Jesus while rejecting Christian doctrine. Goreh’s letter addresses them directly, arguing the case for the faith he had come to accept.

A note on the text. A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares is in the public domain. What you’re buying is our edition: the careful typesetting and correction. The original text is also available free here.

That free scan runs about 13.2 errors per 1,000 characters (OCR mistakes, stray marks, broken words). Our edition corrects them.

Related reading

More like this

We publish first-person accounts of changed lives, and translate works into English that have never been in it. Pick what you want to hear about — nothing is pre-selected, and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe.

What would you like to hear about?

Choose at least one — we won’t collect an address we have no permission to use.

Read the original scan ↗

The free scan

Digitised by Google. This is the same file you would get by following the link — we keep a copy so you do not have to leave.

Or read the original scan ↗

Our corrected edition of A Letter to the Brahmos from a Converted Brahman of Benares — $6.99